30 Judge John Hodgman Inside Jokes

Random Observation/Comment #730: I love fake internet courtrooms. Please solve all my disputes.

Why this List?

I’m a completionist when it comes to devouring content and podcasts. My recent revisit to Judge John Hodgman made me realize that there’s something comforting in a fake internet courtroom. The little arguments are petty and pedantic, but the judge is just so wise and eloquent.

I wouldn’t request my wife to listen to all the episodes of Judge John Hodgman by Maximumfun (like I have been doing), so here are some summary of rulings and quirks she’ll want to know when we submit a case.

  1. A hotdog is not a sandwich (even though Merriam-Webster says so and uses every chance to bring it up)

  2. “You like what you like” rule – You’re allowed to have your little weirdsies

  3. “It’s not helping unless you’re helping in the way you’re asked to help.”

  4. “Be mindful of the work you leave for others”

  5. How have you been harmed or damaged? If the person hasn’t, then let them be

  6. There’s a statistic of the judge ruling against the husband. We love his consistency.

  7. Cast iron is always the way to go.

  8. Refrain from submitting a spreadsheet as evidence because it will count against you

  9. Driver gets to choose the music

  10. Jesse’s reaction to cute cat and dog photos is the best thing ever. Try not to pander to the bailiff.

  11. “Alexa, play Huey Lewis and the News – Sports” is one of the best recurring jokes by Jesse

  12. People who leave unfinished time on a microwave are monsters

  13. Cultural references are obscure and the beginning will likely start with “All guesses are wrong!” – guess “song by the Mountain Goats” or “Star Wars reference”

  14. The judge does not have a sweet tooth, but an alcohol molar

  15. “Collections are showcased” – The difference between a hoard and a collection is the method of display

  16. Judge loves Scrabble and hates Boggle

  17. “If you know you’re sneaking, then you’re sneaking”

  18. Draculas can be everywhere and anywhere – bailiff Jesse is an expert in deciding

  19. “Hambone” is the perfect pet name – So are other pet names ending in vowels like mango and papaya

  20. “Marinate that leftover burrito stump” is a great callback to reference

  21. “I’ll have the kung pao chicken” is in reference to an episode of a bad dad joke, but dad jokes are great

  22. The judge exclusively does research via Wikipedia and urban dictionary.

  23. Always be plugging – Vacationland: True Stories from Painful BeachesMedallion Status: True Stories from Secret Rooms, Dicktown (on Hulu)

  24. The judge is an only child, but never brings it up during the hearing

  25. The judge hates mayonnaise

  26. Judge John Hodgman definitely spends all his knowledge on sports

  27. The judge loves “is x food a y food” arguments between heterosexual married couples

  28. Die Hard is a great Christmas movie

  29. Say you know the crux of the situation

  30. The court loves compromises and does not just judge in one person’s favors

Let the record show that this post and those last few list items were in jest and not to sway my wife to make any “mistakes” during any future hearing.

For those curious of the case, we have not submitted anything officially, but essentially: my wife hates that I wear bone conductor headphones (Aeropex by Aftershokz) all the time (around 10 hrs a day). I have had these for 2+ years and I don’t notice that I put them on anymore. My wife wants me to stop wearing them when we host any events or see friends. I personally try to take them off before events if I remember to consciously do so, but I counter request my wife doesn’t forcefully take them off my head. I’m not always listening to something, but I don’t think I need to constantly take them off and put them on or it defeats the purpose of the headset.

~See Lemons Love JJHO